Tell me what stayed with you—I read every message. Your thoughts might even shape what the Quiet Jury hears next on Patreon.

🎙 MURDERESS REPLAY: #9 Belle Gunness

April 1908. A farmhouse in La Porte, Indiana burns to the ground. When investigators sift through the ashes, they find more than charred timbers. Buried on the property are bodies — dozens of them — each pointing to the same woman at the center of the mystery: Belle Gunness.

In this Murderess Replay, host Sidney and his old co-host, Jamie, revisit the story of America’s most infamous black widow. From her early life as a Norwegian immigrant to the trail of suitors who vanished after answering her personal ads, this episode explores how Belle lured men with promises of love and land, only for them to disappear into the soil of her farm.

It’s a case that blends legend and fact, leaving behind one question that still haunts true crime history: did Belle die in the fire, or escape to kill again?