In this episode, we examine the tragic case of 19-year-old Tyler Marie Thomas, who vanished on December 2, 2010, after leaving a party at Peru State College. Despite being close to her dorm, Ty disappeared into the freezing night after sending a distressing text to friends. We cover the unsettling aftermath, including Joshua Keadle’s changing stories, and his eventual conviction for her murder. Though Keadle was found guilty and awarded damages, Ty’s body remains missing.