Seltzer Kings presents a chilling new scripted audio special that reimagines Wellsville’s most mysterious ice cream man as something far darker than childhood nostalgia remembers. Blending true-crime documentary style with 90s cult classic energy, the project peeks behind the mask to reveal a tale of obsession, horror, and suburban legend.

Starring:

Danny Tamberelli (⁠@dtamberelli⁠) (⁠@dannytamberelli⁠)

Michael C. Maronna (⁠@michaelcmaronna⁠)

Jeremy Balon (⁠@jeremybalon⁠)

Mr. Tastee

Zac Fieldsend (⁠@zacfieldsend⁠)

Jake Smith (⁠@jakesmith4490⁠)

Al Delgado

Courtney Maginnis (⁠@courtmaginnis⁠)

Written by:

Zac Fieldsend (⁠@zacfieldsend⁠)

Produced by:

Jeremy Balon (⁠@jeremybalon⁠)

Network:

Seltzer Kings (⁠seltzerkings.com⁠) (⁠@seltzerkingspodcasts⁠)

Website: ⁠seltzerkings.com/nightmare-on-memory-lane⁠

Linktree: ⁠linktr.ee/seltzerkings⁠

Voicemail: (347) 470-8150

Theme Music by

Valharmony via EE

Tastee Basement Music by

⁠Hugh Manker and his Stardusters⁠ (1950)

Check out our "Nightmare on Memory Lane" Merchandise!

https://www.seltzerkings.com/shop/

Legal

Nightmare on Memory Lane is copyright © 2025 Seltzer Kings, LLC and intended for entertainment purposes only. Seltzer Kings, LLC is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by Nickelodeon, Viacom, or any of their subsidiaries. All opinions, stories, and creative interpretations expressed within are parody and solely those of the creators and performers. Listener discretion is advised.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Seltzer Kings presents a chilling new scripted audio special that reimagines Wellsville’s most mysterious ice cream man as something far darker than childhood nostalgia remembers. Blending true-crime documentary style with 90s cult classic energy, the project peeks behind the mask to reveal a tale of obsession, horror, and suburban legend.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices