Evangelical celebrity preachers are warning their followers against being sucked-in to the current upswing in Libertarian thinking in America. Their concern is that this sort of thinking is atheistic, and inescapably so. Christian Libertarians are often chided that the label is an oxymoron. How can a Christian adopt that philosophy? We answer that with another question: How can there be any such thing as atheistic libertarianism? Christianity is the only solid ground for consistent libertarian thinking.