Send us Fan Mail

In the early hours of September 4, 2023, a passing driver discovered the body of 19-year-old Noah Presgrove lying naked on the side of U.S. Highway 81 near Terral, Oklahoma — wearing only two mismatched shoes. What followed was a chain of confusion, silence, and unanswered questions that continues nearly two years later.

In this one-hour investigative special, Dustin Terry of TheColdCases.com takes you through the full story — from Noah’s final night at a Labor Day party and the ATV crash that preceded it, to the baffling autopsy results, family-filed lawsuit, and the lingering possibility of a cover-up.

Through meticulous research and careful narration, this episode exposes the inconsistencies, missing timeline, and legal twists that have left a family searching for justice.

What really happened on that dark Oklahoma highway?
Someone knows.

Support the show

🎙️ At TheColdCases.com, we bring attention to cold cases, unsolved crimes, and forgotten crimes through powerful true crime stories and investigative journalism.

👉 Support our work by checking out our exclusive resources through our affiliate links inside this podcast:
• Citizen Detective PDF – Learn how to investigate cold cases responsibly.
• Criminal Psychology Crash Course – Understand the minds behind the crimes.
• Top Ten Cold Cases Across the USA PDF – Explore some of the most haunting mysteries still unsolved.

👉 Every download helps keep the podcast alive and continues shining a light on victims and families still waiting for justice.