Welcome back to "This Day in Scottish History." I'm your host, Colin MacDonald. Today, we're delving into a moment that sparked a revolutionary shift in medical treatment and the understanding of the human mind. On November 13, 1841, Scottish surgeon James Braid attended a demonstration in Manchester, England, that set him on a path to become the father of modern hypnotism.

Born in Kinross, Scotland, in 1795, Braid was a well-established surgeon by the time he witnessed the now-famous demonstration by French mesmerist Charles Lafontaine. Lafontaine claimed to use “animal magnetism,” which he asserted could influence his subjects through a mysterious, unseen force. Braid, a skeptic of such mystical claims, initially believed mesmerism was nothing more than illusion or the product of an overly active imagination. But on this day, he saw something that he could not explain away: one of Lafontaine's subjects, under trance, seemed genuinely unable to open their eyes.

Curious, Braid decided to conduct his own experiments to understand this phenomenon. He noticed that by simply having a subject focus intently on an object, often a small, bright one, they could enter a trance-like state with no need for the magnetic “passes” Lafontaine employed. Braid found that this induced state was not dependent on any supernatural force but rather was a natural response involving intense concentration and suggestion. Braid’s observations inspired him to coin a new term for this phenomenon: "hypnotism," from the Greek word hypnos, meaning sleep, although he quickly clarified that the trance he induced wasn’t the same as ordinary sleep.

This discovery led him to publish his landmark book Neurypnology in 1843, in which he outlined his theory that hypnotic effects were solely the result of a specific physiological condition of the nervous system rather than some magnetic fluid or mystical energy. His revolutionary approach rejected the mystical explanations that mesmerists embraced and placed hypnotism firmly within the realm of science. Braid was adamant that hypnotism was not a “universal remedy” or cure-all but could serve as a valuable tool within medicine, especially in treating certain nervous disorders.

What made Braid’s approach remarkable was his commitment to grounding hypnotism in empirical observation and experimentation, aligning it with principles of physiology and psychology. Through his careful documentation and methodical approach, he legitimized hypnotism within medical circles, opening the door for its use in both therapy and surgical procedures. For instance, Braid was a pioneer in exploring the use of hypnotism as a form of anesthesia, well before chemical anesthesia became common practice in surgery.

His work in hypnotism was just one aspect of his illustrious medical career. Known for his skills as a surgeon, Braid had performed hundreds of successful operations, including groundbreaking treatments for conditions like clubfoot and spinal curvature. Yet, his legacy would be most deeply felt in his pioneering work in hypnotism, which, thanks to his efforts, grew from a fringe practice into a field that gained scientific respectability.

However, Braid’s work did not go unchallenged. The notion of hypnotism—especially one untethered from religious or mystical interpretations—faced strong opposition. In fact, he drew the ire of the clergy, particularly in 1842, when a clergyman named Hugh Boyd McNeile in Liverpool denounced hypnotism as a form of “Satanic agency.” Braid, unflinching, defended his scientific position, even offering McNeile an invitation to attend one of his lectures, hoping to clarify misconceptions. Unfortunately, McNeile declined, and the controversy continued. Nonetheless, Braid stood firm in his belief that hypnotism was a natural and valuable phenomenon rooted in the workings of the mind and body.

By challenging and scientifically redefining hypnotism, Braid’s work laid the groundwork for modern hypnotherapy. His influence extended internationally, especially in France, where pioneers like Étienne Eugène Azam, Paul Broca, and Ambroise-Auguste Liébeault built upon his findings. Today, Braid’s influence can be seen in therapeutic practices that utilize suggestion, concentration, and focus to help treat psychological conditions.

As we reflect on the events of November 13, 1841, we remember James Braid as a trailblazer who used science to unravel the mysteries of the human mind, sparking a legacy that lives on in both medicine and psychology.

Thank you for joining us for another journey through history. Be sure to tune in tomorrow for more fascinating stories on "This Day in Scottish History." I’m Colin MacDonald, and as always, Haste Ye Back!

This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bagtown.substack.com