Welcome back to This Day in Scottish History. I’m your host, Colin MacDonald. Today, we delve into a defining moment in Scotland’s past. On November 17, 1292, the fate of the Scottish throne was decided in a landmark ruling by a panel of auditors led by Edward I of England. Their decision declared John Balliol the rightful King of Scots, ending years of uncertainty but setting the stage for turmoil that would shape Scotland’s future.

The events leading up to this decision were steeped in tragedy and tension. In 1286, King Alexander III died suddenly, leaving his granddaughter Margaret, the Maid of Norway, as his sole heir. At just three years old, Margaret’s rule required the guidance of the Guardians of Scotland, a group of nobles tasked with governing the realm. However, Margaret’s untimely death in 1290 left Scotland without a clear successor.

Thirteen claimants came forward to vie for the throne. The two strongest claims belonged to John Balliol and Robert de Brus, the 5th Lord of Annandale. Balliol argued his right to the crown based on primogeniture, the principle of inheritance through the eldest line, while Brus emphasized proximity of blood, claiming he was a generation closer to the late King Alexander III.

Fearing the outbreak of civil war, the Guardians sought the help of Edward I of England to mediate. This decision would prove controversial. Edward agreed to arbitrate but demanded recognition as Scotland’s feudal overlord, a claim deeply resented by the Scots. Desperate to avoid conflict, the Guardians had little choice but to concede to Edward’s demands.

Edward convened a court of 104 auditors to hear the cases. He personally appointed 24 of them and presided over the proceedings. Balliol and Brus were each allowed to appoint 40 auditors of their own, ensuring their interests were represented. The cases were argued passionately, with each side presenting evidence and appeals rooted in both legal precedent and Scottish tradition.

Balliol’s claim was straightforward. His mother, Devorguilla of Galloway, was the eldest daughter of Margaret of Huntingdon, sister of William the Lion. By primogeniture, Balliol’s line had the strongest hereditary right to the throne. Brus, however, countered with the argument of proximity, claiming his descent through a younger line brought him closer in blood to Alexander III.

Other claimants, such as John Hastings and Floris V, Count of Holland, presented their own arguments, but none matched the strength of Balliol’s or Brus’s claims. Hastings, for example, proposed that the kingdom be divided among the descendants of Margaret of Huntingdon, an idea that was swiftly rejected.

On November 17, 1292, the court rendered its decision. Edward ruled in favor of John Balliol, recognizing primogeniture as the guiding principle for succession. Balliol was crowned King of Scots shortly thereafter, but his reign was overshadowed by Edward’s interference.

Edward treated Scotland as a vassal state, frequently summoning Balliol to English courts and overturning his decisions. This heavy-handed approach earned Balliol the nickname “Toom Tabard,” or “Empty Coat,” reflecting his lack of real authority. The Scots grew increasingly resentful of Edward’s overreach, and tensions boiled over in 1296 when rebellion erupted, marking the beginning of the Wars of Scottish Independence.

Though the Great Cause resolved the immediate question of succession, it exposed Scotland’s vulnerability during a time of interregnum. Edward’s ambitions and Balliol’s weak rule plunged Scotland into conflict, but it also galvanized the Scottish people in their struggle for freedom. Figures like William Wallace and, later, Robert the Bruce emerged as leaders in the fight for independence.

The events of November 17, 1292, are a reminder of the complexities of leadership and the enduring spirit of the Scottish people. While the decision to crown Balliol brought temporary resolution, it set the stage for a long and arduous fight for Scotland’s sovereignty.

Thank you for joining me on This Day in Scottish History. I’m Colin MacDonald. Haste ye back tomorrow for another exploration of Scotland’s rich and dramatic past.

This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bagtown.substack.com