Welcome to "This Day in Scottish History." I’m your host, Colin MacDonald, and today we’re delving into a pivotal moment in the world of craft brewing. On November 26, 2009, BrewDog, a then-upstart Scottish brewery based in Fraserburgh, launched a beer that would go on to redefine the possibilities of brewing: Tactical Nuclear Penguin. This wasn’t just a beer—it was a declaration of intent from a company determined to push boundaries and challenge the status quo. With an alcohol content of 32%, it was the strongest beer ever made at the time and a product of remarkable craftsmanship, innovation, and just a bit of controversy.

At its heart, Tactical Nuclear Penguin is an imperial stout, a style known for its rich, bold flavors and higher alcohol content. But BrewDog took this style to uncharted territory. The beer began as a robust 10% ABV imperial stout, brewed with a careful balance of dark malts to create deep notes of chocolate and roasted coffee. It was then aged for 16 months—eight months in Isle of Arran whisky casks and another eight in Islay casks. This aging process infused the beer with layers of complexity, including hints of peat smoke, oak, and the signature flavors of Scotland’s whisky heritage.

The real magic, however, came after aging. To achieve its record-breaking 32% ABV, the beer underwent a meticulous freezing process. BrewDog stored it at -20°C for three weeks, periodically removing the ice that formed. This technique—essentially freeze distillation—concentrated the alcohol content and intensified the stout’s already bold flavors. The result was a beer that combined the depth of a fine whisky with the richness of an imperial stout.

Tactical Nuclear Penguin wasn’t a beer to be chugged or casually consumed. BrewDog packaged it with a resealable stopper, encouraging drinkers to savor it in small measures, much like a fine whisky. At £30 per bottle, or £250 if you also wanted a share in the brewery, it was a high-end product aimed squarely at connoisseurs. The beer’s flavor profile was as bold as its concept. Rich notes of dark chocolate and roasted coffee dominated, underscored by a pronounced whisky character from its time in casks. Smoky and warming, it offered a tasting experience unlike any other beer of its time.

The launch of Tactical Nuclear Penguin wasn’t without its share of controversy. Its release coincided with the introduction of Scotland’s Alcohol Bill, which aimed to combat alcohol abuse by introducing a minimum price for alcohol. Critics accused BrewDog of poor timing and accused the brewery of attention-seeking. Public health groups like Alcohol Focus Scotland condemned the beer, arguing it sent the wrong message amid growing concerns over binge drinking.

BrewDog co-founder James Watt countered that the beer’s high price, limited availability, and niche appeal made it an unlikely culprit for irresponsible drinking. Instead, Watt pointed the finger at major brewers and supermarkets, whose cheap, mass-produced alcohol was far more accessible. He emphasized that Tactical Nuclear Penguin was meant to elevate beer to the status of fine whisky or wine, encouraging people to appreciate it slowly and responsibly.

This wasn’t BrewDog’s first brush with controversy. Earlier that year, they had released Tokyo, an 18.2% ABV stout, which faced backlash for its provocative label suggesting that "moderation itself should be moderated." BrewDog thrived on being the industry’s disruptor, and Tactical Nuclear Penguin solidified their reputation as rebels willing to challenge conventions.

Although only 500 bottles of Tactical Nuclear Penguin were produced, its impact on the craft beer world was profound. It inspired other breweries to experiment with extreme beers and elevated the perception of beer as a complex and premium beverage. The beer also paved the way for BrewDog’s later experiments, including Sink the Bismarck! (41% ABV) and the infamous The End of History (55% ABV), which was released in taxidermied animals and took the title of the world’s strongest beer. Each of these releases cemented BrewDog’s reputation as pioneers of the craft beer revolution.

Today, BrewDog is a global brand, with bars and breweries around the world. Yet, the release of Tactical Nuclear Penguin remains a defining moment—a bold step that helped shape the brewery’s identity and the future of craft brewing.

Tactical Nuclear Penguin wasn’t just about breaking records; it was about pushing boundaries and redefining what beer could be. From its intricate aging process in whisky casks to its innovative freeze distillation method, it showcased the creativity and daring that BrewDog has come to symbolize. While it’s no longer available, its legacy endures in the craft beer movement and in BrewDog’s continued commitment to innovation. It remains a testament to Scotland’s role as a leader in the world of fine drinks—whether that’s whisky or, in this case, an unforgettable imperial stout.

Thank you for joining me today on this frosty adventure through brewing history. I’m Colin MacDonald, and as always, haste ye back!

This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bagtown.substack.com