NY Giants Weekly

By Gotham Sports NetworkSports

NY Giants Weekly episodes

September 29 9: JJ McCarthy Traded to the Giants! Starting QB Imminent? + Defense Exposed vs Titans
The New York Giants have pulled off a stunner, trading a 2027 5th-round pick to the Minnesota Vikings to acquire former first-round quarterback JJ McCarthy. With Jaxson Dart sidelined and Brian Burns suffering a season-ending torn ACL, the front office made it loud and clear that they refuse to throw in the towel on the season. Ethan and Weis break down why McCarthy is a much better scheme fit than Jameis Winston, why Winston was always meant as a short-term backup, and how quickly McCarthy could realistically see the field.
Despite grinding out an ugly Week 3 victory over Cam Ward and the Tennessee Titans, the performance left serious concerns on the table. The guys dive into a fiery debate over the pass rush after top draft picks Abdul Carter and Kayvon Thibodeaux combined for zero sacks, zero QB hits, and just one tackle against a struggling offense. While Weis argues the secondary's inability to cover quick drops handicapped the front, Ethan is completely out of excuses for high-priced, high-draft capital rushers.
Looking ahead to Week 4, the Giants prepare for a sneaky trap game against the Arizona Cardinals at MetLife Stadium. Plus, Ethan and Weis scan the rest of the league, debating which NFL head coach is on the hottest seat, reacting to horrific officiating in the Rams game, and evaluating whether Jim Harbaugh could genuinely face a mid-season exit. Make sure to like the video, leave your thoughts on the JJ McCarthy trade in the comments below, and subscribe for weekly Giants coverage!
03:13 Giants' quarterback strategy
06:32 Discussing quarterback trades and options
11:03 Discussing Jameis and team strategy
13:43 Discussing Jameis Winston's backup role
16:49 Discussing Jameis Winston's role
22:23 Discussing a disappointing draft pick
23:09 Expectations for defensive line performance
28:14 Evaluating the Giants' defense
31:04 Discussing vindication in arguments
33:32 Cardinals' strategic play analysis
37:51 Chargers upcoming schedule predictions
43:47 NFL playoff caliber discussion
44:13 49ers' season despite injuries
45 min
September 23 8: Jaxson Dart is (probably) out for the season | What happens now?
The New York Giants’ season has been turned completely upside down following a devastating Monday Night Football loss to the Rams and a potentially season-ending knee injury to franchise rookie quarterback Jaxson Dart. Ethan, Weis and Nick break down the raw emotional fallout, the immediate pivot to Jameis Winston under center, and why this particular setback hurts far worse than previous lost seasons. With winnable games on the immediate horizon, the crew debates how Matt Nagy and the offensive staff must redesign the game plan to keep New York competitive.
Beyond the quarterback room, the panel tackles the major systematic issues plaguing both sides of the ball. From offensive line struggles and Theo Johnson’s missed assignments to Malik Nabers being targeted only once while trailing, the offensive execution fell flat. Meanwhile, frustration boils over regarding the defense: despite massive draft capital and financial investments, the front four failed to create consistent pressure, leaving an already fragile, struggling secondary entirely exposed.
Finally, the hosts establish their non-negotiable expectations for the remainder of the year. Adamantly rejecting calls to start looking at NFL Mock Drafts in late September, the guys explain why a "Tankathon" mindset destroys locker-room culture and demand that this roster finds a way to win 6 or 7 games with Winston. Drop a comment below with your thoughts on Dart's injury, Winston’s ceiling, and whether the defensive coaching staff is on the hot seat. Don't forget to like, subscribe, and leave a 5-star review!
03:26 Disappointment with Jaxson Dart's Future
08:11 Team's performance and quarterback issues
12:28 Discussing Jameis and Giants' Strategy
13:31 Adjusting the offensive strategy
16:15 Discussing quarterback strategy
22:24 Discussing defense and pressure strategies
23:29 Drafting Arvell Reese
28:17 Sports fan reactions and comparisons
31:03 Reflecting on our place in the universe
32 min
September 14 7: Bully Ball is Back: Giants Dominate Cowboys in Week 1 | John Harbaugh Era begins with Authority
The New York Giants are officially back, kicking off the John Harbaugh era with a massive 28-20 Week 1 victory over the Dallas Cowboys. Ethan, Weis, and Nick return to break down how the team finally played 60 minutes of physical "bully ball" against a bitter division rival. After years of frustration, this new coaching regime has immediately shifted the organization's mindset from hoping for a win to expecting one.
The crew dives deep into Jaxson Dart's phenomenal opening performance, highlighting his elite command of the line of scrimmage and instant chemistry with tight end Isaiah Likely. We also examine the completely revamped offensive line, praising rookie Francis Maui Noa for a flawless debut featuring zero pressures allowed. Together, the relentless ground game and an imposing front five completely punished the Dallas defense to control the clock.
While the victory is sweet, we still analyze glaring concerns in the secondary and debate whether a trade for a cornerback like Joey Porter Jr. is necessary to survive the season. We also give our unfiltered thoughts on Tyrone Tracy's ball security issues and laugh at the struggles of other teams around the league. Subscribe, leave a five-star review, and join the conversation as we follow this new-look Giants roster
03:25 Giants dominate Cowboys at MetLife Stadium
07:08 Giants' disciplined win over Dallas
12:34 Building chemistry with receivers
13:29 Offensive strategy and unpredictability
19:29 Giants' unstoppable running game
22:43 Discussing player performance issues
23:22 Tracy's Issues with Ball Security
28:15 Drafting an offensive lineman over Downs
32:13 Giants' Offensive Line Struggles
33:39 Great offensive lines comparison
38:37 Analyzing defensive performance
41:33 Questioning the defensive line's strength
46:12 Improving special teams performance
49:04 Discussing the Titans' offseason hype
52 min
January 15 6: HARBAUGH MANIA: New York Giants Land John Harbaugh and Instantly RESTORE Franchise Respectability
New York Giants score a franchise-redefining win by landing John Harbaugh as head coach, sparking hope and credibility after years in the wilderness. Can Harbaugh revive the team’s culture and restore the winning standard lost since Tom Coughlin’s departure? The stakes couldn’t be higher, with ownership pulling out all the stops—Chris Mara and Steve Tisch leading the charge, and a rumored $100 million contract on the table—to secure the NFL’s proven program builder.
Ethan, Weis, and Nick break down the full-court press that brought Harbaugh to New York, the impact on the Giants’ coaching staff, and what this means for the power dynamic with GM Joe Schoen. Key topics include building the Giants’ floor for consistent playoff contention, potential defensive coordinator hires like Jim Leonhard, and comparisons to Andy Reid’s transformative role with the Chiefs. Is this the dawn of a new era for Giants football, or will old challenges linger?
48 min
January 05 5: Dysfunction: Giants Ownership UNCERTAINTY Fuels Coaching Rumors – Joe Schoen survives
New York Giants face organizational chaos as ownership uncertainty and a potential front office shakeup threaten to derail their head coach search. Can Jackson Dart’s rookie promise make the Giants job the most coveted opening, or will dysfunction scare away top candidates like Kevin Stefanski and Robert Saleh?

Ethan, Weis and Nick debate Giants’ internal power struggles, dissect the legacy of Brian Daboll’s firing, and scrutinize why mismatched GM and coach timelines undermine the team’s future. They break down why Stefanski headlines the coaching shortlist, question the appeal of competing roles in Las Vegas and Atlanta, and spotlight under-the-radar coordinators like Chris Shula and Jesse Minter. Giants fans craving roster clarity and decisive leadership won’t want to miss this candid analysis of what’s next for Big Blue.

04:11 Why Brian Dabel Was Fired

06:48 "Giants' Dysfunctional Ownership Issues"

11:58 "Rehiring Proven NFL Coaches"

13:21 "Coaching Uncertainty and Challenges"

17:57 "Management Chaos and Uncertainty"

20:13 "Stable Quarterback Situation Highlighted"

24:36 "Joe Shane's Key Decision"

28:19 "Top Coaching Options Ranked"

31:36 Chargers DC Maximizes Player Potential

32:24 "Coaching Growth and Leadership Impact"

35:45 Baltimore Offense and Coaching Uncertainty

40:36 "Harbaugh Unlikely for Giants"

42:54 Ownership Issues and Player Performance

46:19 Giants vs. Raiders Comparison

48:38 "Quarterbacks and Draft Decisions"

51:37 "Unclear Direction, High Stakes"

55:46 "FanDuel Podcast Sign-Off"

57 min
December 16, 2025 4: The Giants are the worst franchise in the NFL
The New York Giants, a once a proud franchise are now amongst the worst franchises in all of professional sports over the last ten years. Nick and Weis discuss the fallout of another disastrous loss, why the coach doesn't matter if the GM sucks, why the ownership group struggles harshly to adapt with the times and breakdown the best case scenario for the rest of the way.
48 min
November 25, 2025 3: Giants waste virtuoso Jameis Winston performance and fire Shane Bowen | What's next?
New York Giants blow another late lead, this time in overtime to the Detroit Lions. On Monday, interim head coach Mike Kafka fired defensive coordinator Shane Bowen for his role in the team's utter collapse.

Hosts Nick and Weis breakdown the Giants' organizational problems, why optics are increasingly becoming a problem and most importantly, why Joe Schoen cannot continue as general manager if the Giants are serious about winning.
53 min
November 17, 2025 2: EMBArRASSING: Giants blow another 4th quarter lead | Abdul Carter likes naps | Shane Bowen is a deadman walking
The New York Giants once again showed they were a long way from being a quality NFL team on Sunday, is there anything left for viewers to watch?

Join hosts Ethan, Nick and Weis for a round table discussion breaking down the latest in the Giants disfunction. Topics covered include Abdul Carter sleeping through a walkthrough and being benched the first series, Jaylin Hyatt giving up on the game sealing interception, Mike Kafka's first game as head coach and run through a long list of head coaching candidates after the season.
44 min
November 10, 2025 1: FIRED: Brian Daboll canned after humiliating loss to Bears
The New York Giants are once again at an organizational crossroads after firing head coach Brian Daboll. Does the front office have a plan?

Join hosts Ethan, Weis and Nick for this conversation about the direction of the team. Topics covered include: Why Daboll needed to be fired as soon as possible and his usage of Jaxson Dart was negligent, how general manager Joe Schoen has insulated himself from blame in the front office, react to the news that Schoen will lead the search for Daboll's replacement and air grievances for yet another lost Giants season.
31 min
November 03, 2025 Giants Collapse Again: Brian Daboll’s Fate Sealed? Jackson Dart Shines Amid Chaos
The Giants hit rock bottom again. Ethan and Weis break down another humiliating loss to the 49ers, calling out coaching failures, player accountability, and why Brian Daboll may already be finished in New York. From Dexter Lawrence’s drop off to Deonte Banks’ struggles, this episode pulls no punches on a franchise in free fall.

The guys also debate whether the Giants should trade for a WR like Jaylen Waddle or Chris Olave, what’s next for Jackson Dart’s development, and how bad roster construction has doomed this regime from the start.

37 min