In the border town of Brownsville, Texas, a tragic story unfolded that blurred the lines between traditional family values, obsession, and the dark world of folk magic. Albert Joseph "Joey" Fischer was a popular 18-year-old student at a prestigious Catholic academy, known for his intelligence, athletic prowess on the basketball court, and sharp, sarcastic wit. His life was cut short in a manner that seemed entirely disconnected from his bright future.
In 1992, Joey began a relationship with a quiet classmate named Christina. While their romance seemed typical for high schoolers, it took a dark turn due to the intense involvement of Christina’s mother, Dora. Coming from a background where traditional values and curanderismo (shamanic healing and folk magic) played a significant role, Dora viewed Joey not just as a boyfriend, but as a guaranteed future son-in-law. When Joey gave Christina a family heirloom ring, Dora interpreted it as a binding engagement.
However, the relationship did not last. Feeling the pressure of Dora’s overbearing presence—which included rumors of her trying to legally change Christina's last name to his—Joey ended the relationship in June 1992. He wanted to enjoy his youth and eventually go to university. The breakup triggered a bizarre and increasingly desperate series of events. Dora contacted Joey’s father to complain about the split and even offered Joey a monthly bribe of $500 to continue dating her daughter. Joey refused and demanded his family ring back, which further incensed the mother.
As the new school year began in 1993, Joey moved on and started dating another girl. For Dora, this was an unforgivable insult to her family's honor. She turned to a 70-year-old fortune teller and folk healer named Maria Martinez. Dora initially sought spells to bring Joey back, but when that failed, her request turned lethal. She decided that Joey had to be eliminated for "shaming" her daughter.
The plan was set in motion through Daniel Garza, a man who visited the fortune teller seeking help for his own failing marriage. Maria convinced Daniel that if he helped a "client" (Dora) get rid of a young man, his own personal problems would be solved through magic, and he would receive a payment of several thousand dollars. Daniel, believing in the supernatural power of the healer, hired two hitmen from Mexico to carry out the deed.
On the morning of March 3, 1993, Joey was in his driveway washing his mother's car before school. An assassin approached him from behind and fired three shots, killing him instantly. The killers fled, leaving behind a crime scene with almost no leads, except for one small, unintentional clue: a business card for a bail bond office that had fallen from the perpetrator's pocket during the struggle.
Detectives noticed a distinctive, flowery way the number "4" was written on the card. This specific handwriting matched a bail application filed by a man recently processed in the system, which led investigators directly to Daniel Garza. Upon his arrest, Daniel confessed, detailing the involvement of the fortune teller and the mother who had orchestrated the hit.
The subsequent legal proceedings were complex, involving recorded conversations where Dora discussed paying off the participants. Ultimately, the justice system delivered stern verdicts. Dora Cisneros and Daniel Garza were sentenced to life in prison. Maria Martinez received 20 years for her role as the intermediary. Ironically, the two hitmen who actually carried out the shooting received sentences of 15 years. This case remains a haunting example of how maternal obsession and superstition can lead to an unthinkable and absurd crime.


Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/missing-pieces--6886558/support.