While Mary and Sorrowful prepare to search for the lost city of Gold in the Orinoco, the crew of the Caliban have a very different challenge ahead: get their old buddy Sam Axe off scott free for borrowing a ship. The puritans of Providence Island have secrets that they guard on this island, secrets that many are eager to steal from them... Will this new alliance succeed? Or will it be cast asunder before it can even set sail?