The Kansas City Chiefs live to fight another day, while the Indianapolis Colts let a golden opportunity slip away in overtime. In one of the most baffling decisions of the game, Shane Steichen went away from using Jonathan Taylor — the best running back in the league — leading to a string of costly three-and-outs that completely shifted the momentum.

With the offense stalling, the Colts’ defense was stuck on the field far too long, eventually wearing down as Kansas City capitalized in OT. What looked like a game Indy should have closed out instead turned into a frustrating collapse.