[00:00] Into the Darkness: Picking Up Part II

[04:50] Elevator Tragedy & Frank Carroll’s Ghost

[05:52] Spirit Box Fires Up

[11:11] Lights Out in the Mine

[12:16] Enter Chip Coffey (With Flair, Obviously)

[13:56] Psychic Drama Underground

[21:32] Shaft Session (lol, shaft): Night Three Begins

[30:16] Jersey Fred Weighs In

[32:59] An Offering to the Miners

[34:08] Haunted or Hoax?

Paranormal Playback heads back underground for Part II of Kindred Spirits Season 4, Episode 9: What Lies Beneath.

This time, Amy Bruni and Adam Berry dig deeper into Sterling Hill Mine with psychic Chip Coffey, EVP experiments, and one very restless spirit. Frank Carroll, the hoist operator blamed for a deadly elevator accident in the 1950s, may still be trying to clear his name from beyond the grave. From spirit box drama and blackout scares to shadow figures peeking from the tunnels, Mel and Lor unpack it all with humor, skepticism, and a little chaos.

👻 Want more? Visit our website for photos, source materials, and ghostly extras.

While you’re here, don’t forget to:

⭐️ Rate, review, and subscribe wherever you listen

👻 Share Paranormal Playback with a friend who loves reality TV or spooky stories

📲 Follow us on Instagram and TikTok for behind-the-scenes chaos, sneak peeks, and bonus hauntings

📞 Got a ghost story of your own? Send it in, you might just hear it in a future Tales from the Shadows.

Paranormal Playback is your weekly deep dive into spooky reality TV, ghost hunts, dramatic reenactments, and enough EVP to raise the dead. Hosted by Charlie Holley, Melanie Malone, & Lauren Sanders.

Each episode has its own gallery on our website to explore while you listen.

→ Instgram @paranormalplayback

→ TikTok @paranormal.playba

→ ☎️ VM: (404) 981-4533

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.