There’s been a robbery at Mr. Crawford’s general store. Staci thinks she saw the culprit, but is warned by a mysterious visitor that if she knows what’s good for her, she’ll keep her mouth shut! Meanwhile, C.J. discovers the hard way that receiving God’s forgiveness isn’t hard at all.

Everyone is excited about Wildwood’s newest and richest student… everyone that is, except Miss Harbor, who quickly realizes that Tiffany doesn’t want to play by anyone’s rules but her own.

Staci’s new toy goes missing and only C.J. knows the truth, but he’s not telling … that is, until he hears a familiar tune.

Just days before Christmas, a mysterious illness spreads through the town sapping everyone of their strength and their hopes of winning the big Christmas decorating contest. With only hours before the judges arrive, can The Club find a way to save Christmas or has everyone been making Christmas something it’s not?

On the way to perform their Christmas pageant in Modesty, The Club, Paw Paw Chuck, and Miss Harbor run into an unexpected delay. Forced to seek shelter in a hillside home, the group help a man and his son find healing, restoration, and a reason to have the Christmas spirit.

During the school gift exchange, Miss Harbor challenges her class not just to appreciate the gift, but spend time being thankful for the giver. Through her challenge, The Club poignantly discovers the depth of God’s love for us.

When gifts begin to mysteriously appear on doorsteps all over Wildwood, Ned and Tiffany join forces to reveal the identity of the “Christmas Gift-Giving Bandit.” What they discover, is a special lesson in God’s goodness and counting His blessings.

C.J.’s in a pickle. He knows God wants him to do something he doesn’t want to do. Captain Gus reminds C.J. of the story of what happened to someone in a similar situation; someone named, Jonah!

The big go-cart race is coming up. But without teamwork, The Club discovers just how hard it is to be on the winning team.

The slick traveling salesman, Dr. Theron promises to teach C.J. the secrets of success and fame. But C.J. must decide whom he wants to follow more, “the good doctor” or “The Good Shepherd.”