We find ourselves in a sticky situation! How does one know when to hold 'em, and know when to fold 'em? So we pour one out for Kenny Rogers, grab a PB&J, and ask guest judge Katie to make the best of a bad hand and pick a winner. Will it be the pride of Georgia-sourced sandwich spreads, or a playful box of paper? Our games this episode: Tattoo Parlor, Hook Up the Trailer, and Hey, That's My Friend! Plus, gluttons for punishment will enjoy our usual jar o' chunky-style outtakes.