Drinks After Work with Shannon and Deb

Performance Reviews: The Corporate Hunger Games

Listen Later

Pop the tab on something cold and settle in — it's time for another round of Drinks After Work!

This time, we're talking all about:

  • Why performance reviews feel like going to the principal's office
  • How the rating system is rigged (spoiler: you're never getting that 5/5)
  • The disconnect between widget-based work and knowledge-based work
  • Why managers wait until the last minute and copy-paste from last year
  • What to do instead if you want actual feedback that matters

    • In this episode, Shannon and Deborah dig into one of corporate America's most dreaded rituals: the annual performance review. From canned responses and forced rankings to managers who "never give out a 10," they break down why this outdated system leaves 80% of employees feeling uninspired and unappreciated. But they don't just vent—they also share practical advice for both managers and employees on how to make feedback meaningful, timely, and actually useful.

    So sip, swig, or chug — and get ready to:

    • Stop waiting until review time to give (or get) critical feedback
    • Learn how to care personally while challenging directly (thank you, Kim Scott)
    • Ask the right questions during job interviews to avoid toxic review cultures
    • Use one-on-ones for coaching instead of just project updates
    • Understand what "good" looks like before you're judged on it

      • Because it wouldn't be Drinks After Work without the drinks, here are the FAB:

      Shannon: Hot Apple Cider with Bourbon — Apple cider simmered with chunked apples, chunked oranges, and cinnamon sticks until reduced, then mixed with bourbon.
      Deborah: Pear Pressure — Vodka, spiced honey syrup, apple cider, lemon, topped with Prosecco.

      Resources: Performance Reviews Are Pointless and Insulting: Why Do They Still Exist? (Forbes, 2018)

      Radical Candor by Kim Scott

      Psychology Today: Less than 20% of employees feel inspired by their review (2024)

      Be part of the Learning Rebels Community.
      Continue the conversation while building connections and capability. Learn more here.
       
      Join the Coffee Chat conversations
      Be part of Learning Rebels live Coffee Chat Discussions! Sign up here.  
       
      Hire Learning Rebels.
      When you need learning that sticks, we’ll fight to make performance results happen. Visit the Learning Rebels website to learn more.
       
      Hosts: Shannon Tipton & Deborah Harris
       
      Podcast produced by: Obsidian Productions
      ...more
      View all episodesView all episodes
      Download on the App Store
      Drinks After Work with Shannon and DebBy Shannon Tipton