In telling her regular story about her parents and the flight to Neverland, and their eventual return to the real world, John and Michael realise what is in fact at risk living in their fantasy land. They beg to return home and the Lost Boys join the plan, much to Peter's frustration, not that he would admit it. Tink agrees to lead them over the sea, and the Redskins get them safely across the island.
 
But it was at that exact moment that the pirates had chosen for their long expected attack on the Lost Boys' home. And what was to be the end of their time in Neverland turns into their most risky adventure.