Perantau Ilmu

Policy Evaluation #2: Ilusi Kebijakan dan Realitas Program Lapangan


Listen Later

The provided sources discuss the conceptual frameworks and practical challenges involved in evaluating complex interventions within social and health policy. They introduce Ray Pawson’s VICTORE mnemonic, which highlights critical dimensions such as individual volition, implementation chains, and environmental contexts that influence programme success. Patricia Rogers further distinguishes between complicated systems, which have many moving parts, and complex systems, which feature emergent behaviors and non-linear feedback loops. Practical applications are explored through diverse case studies, including organ donation protocols, domestic violence legislation, and youth health initiatives. Collectively, the texts argue that standard linear logic models are often insufficient for capturing the unintended consequences and systemic shifts typical of real-world reforms. Consequently, the authors advocate for theory-based, pluralistic research designs that prioritize understanding how and why an intervention works across different settings rather than simply measuring its isolated effectiveness.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Perantau IlmuBy Dimas P. Muharam