Ask most people what their best investment has been and they will tell you about
their home. They bought it for four hundred thousand, it is worth well over a million
now, and the arithmetic looks unanswerable. It is a fair answer to the wrong question.
This episode separates the home decision from the investment decision, and measures
what most households never measure: what the home quietly absorbs. Not the mortgage
you can see, but three things you cannot. The capital that stops working the moment it
goes in. The cashflow that leaves after tax and buys no income. And the one that
actually costs people a portfolio, the borrowing capacity a lender will no longer
extend to you, because an owner-occupier mortgage is serviced entirely out of your
salary while an investment mortgage is part-serviced by a tenant.
We also deal honestly with the argument on the other side, because it just got
stronger. From the first of July 2027 the capital gains discount on established
residential investment property is replaced by indexation with a thirty percent
minimum rate, and rental losses on established dwellings bought after the twelfth of
May 2026 are quarantined rather than deducted against salary. The main residence
exemption was left alone. On tax, the home just widened its lead. That concession is
worth making properly, and it still does not turn the home into an investment.
There is history here too. Capital gains tax arrived in September 1985 and the family
home was exempt from the first day. In 1999 indexation was swapped for a discount. In
2027 we swap back. Forty years of reform, and every one of them walked around the home.
General information and education only, not financial advice. Everyone's position is
different, so take your own numbers to a licensed adviser. Read the full newsletter at
pbco.com.au for the diagrams and the worked math.
Property Notes is the analytical work I do for myself, packaged in a way you can act on with your own accountant. Always speak to a qualified professional before acting on anything discussed.
Subscribe + read the diagrams: https://www.pbco.com.au