Values Investors Podcast | Socially Responsible Investing, ESG, Ethical, Impact, Sustainable Investments

Proxy Season 2025: How Shareholders Are Making an Impact Amid Political Pushback


Listen Later

Proxy Season 2025: How Shareholders Are Making an Impact Amid Political Pushback

At AIO Financial, we specialize in helping our clients align their investments with their values through socially responsible investing (SRI). We believe in the power of the individual investor—and there’s no better example of that power than proxy season, when shareholders come together to hold corporations accountable.

The 2025 Proxy Preview Report, developed by As You Sow, Proxy Impact, and Empower Venture Partners, underscores how shareholder advocacy remains one of the most powerful tools we have to influence corporate behavior—even in the face of increasing political and regulatory headwinds. Link to report: https://www.proxypreview.org/

🗳 What Is Shareholder Advocacy?

Shareholder advocacy refers to the actions taken by investors—often at annual general meetings (AGMs)—to influence a company’s policies, operations, and impact on society and the environment. Through proxy voting and shareholder resolutions, investors can raise concerns about everything from climate change to corporate lobbying practices.

Key Shareholder Rights Include:
  • Voting on board director candidates and policy issues
  • Receiving dividends and reviewing company financials
  • Transferring shares and suing for wrongful acts
  • Filing shareholder proposals—if you’ve held:
    • $2,000+ in stock for 3+ years
    • $15,000+ for 2+ years
    • $25,000+ for 1+ year
    • Shareholders owning more than 10% of a company’s shares can call special meetings, and those with over 5% must file reports to the SEC detailing their intentions and transactions.

      At AIO Financial, we help clients use these rights to vote their values and engage companies on issues like climate justice, racial equity, and sustainable business practices.

      📉 Fewer Filings, Bigger Stakes in 2025

      As of February 21, shareholders had filed 355 ESG proposals—a 34% drop from the same time in 2024. Why?

      1. Regulatory Pushback: A change in the presidential administration led to a dramatic policy shift at the SEC. Resolutions that had been approved for decades were suddenly excluded.
      2. Mid-Season Rule Changes: After most proposals were filed, the SEC altered the rules to favor companies, extending their deadline to object—but not giving shareholders the same opportunity to revise their submissions.
      3. Political Attacks on ESG: Proponents are more cautious this year, with many opting for private negotiations to avoid public backlash and potential proposal exclusions.
      4. Despite fewer filings, shareholder advocacy is more important than ever. This year’s proposals tackle systemic risks that impact long-term corporate value—and your portfolio.

        🌍 2025 Proposal Highlights
        🌡️ Climate Change (85 proposals)
        • Companies are being asked to disclose climate transition plans, reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and report on climate-related financial risks.
        • Shareholders are targeting sectors like finance and insurance for their role in funding fossil fuels and delaying climate action.
        • 🏛️ Corporate Political Influence (77 proposals)
          • Shareholders want transparency around lobbying, political contributions, and values alignment.
          • The SEC allowed omission of some long-standing lobbying disclosure proposals, prompting many investors to shift strategy.
          • 🌱 Environmental Management (52 proposals)
            • Topics include biodiversity, deforestation, plastic use, and food waste.
            • New proposals target the avocado supply chain and pollution from tire particulates.
            • 🧑🏽‍🤝‍🧑🏻 Human Rights (37 proposals)
              • Issues addressed include AI ethics, child safety, forced labor, Indigenous rights, and tax transparency.
              • One high-profile proposal calls on Alphabet to disclose lobbying efforts related to child safety laws.
              • 💼 Diversity, Equity & Inclusion (36 proposals)
                • Proposals ask companies to disclose DEI metrics, ensure equal pay, and protect freedom of association.
                • Despite political backlash, support for DEI remains strong: At companies like Disney and Apple, shareholders voted overwhelmingly (98%) in favor of DEI initiatives.
                • ⚠️ Withdrawing and Omitting Proposals

                  So far, 78 proposals (22%) have been withdrawn—up from just 7.7% last year. These withdrawals often result from successful negotiations behind the scenes or concern over proposals being blocked by the SEC.

                  Meanwhile, 221 proposals have received no-action requests—where companies ask the SEC for permission to exclude them. This tactic has become more frequent in 2025, signaling a more adversarial environment for shareholder rights.

                  🛑 The Anti-ESG Push

                  The number of anti-ESG proposals is rising and now represents nearly 15% of all submissions. These proposals often attack:

                  • DEI programs
                  • Corporate activism
                  • Environmental disclosures
                  • Notably, state officials like Oklahoma’s State Treasurer have joined the push, filing proposals against companies that support racial justice, digital safety, or reproductive rights.

                    The good news? These proposals are overwhelmingly defeated—with anti-DEI efforts losing 98% of the vote.

                    💡 Why This Matters

                    The data is clear: Shareholder advocacy works. Over the last two decades, it has led to:

                    • Greater corporate transparency
                    • Stronger environmental policies
                    • Improved worker protections
                    • More inclusive and equitable workplaces
                    • Even in a politically hostile environment, responsible investors are helping shape the future of business—one vote at a time.

                      ✅ How You Can Make an Impact

                      At AIO Financial, we empower you to:

                      • Vote your proxies in alignment with your values
                      • Engage companies on sustainability and justice
                      • Invest in portfolios screened for ESG performance and advocacy alignment
                      • You don’t need to be a billionaire or run a fund. If you’re a shareholder, you already have a voice—and we’re here to help you use it effectively.

                        📬 Let’s Work Together

                        Want to learn more about socially responsible investing and shareholder advocacy? Reach out today for a free consultation. Whether you’re just starting or you’re a seasoned investor, we’ll help you build a strategy that aligns your money with your mission.

                        🌐 aiofinancial.com
                        📞 Schedule a call
                        📩 Join our newsletter for updates on ESG investing and proxy voting tools

                        Together, we can build a more sustainable and just future—one vote, one investment, one conversation at a time.

                        Video Transcript:

                        I’m going to go over some of the
                        shareholder resolutions that are proposed for 2025
                        there has been a drop in the number of resolutions
                        compared to 2024
                        we’re still just in the beginning of the season
                        but that’s partially because of the new SEC leadership
                        and shifting in rules
                        making it more difficult for shareholders
                        to make resolutions to make changes
                        be advocates shareholders are waiting on this
                        you’ll see a lot of the proposals are under review
                        there’s been an increase in private negotiations
                        so the shareholders
                        are engaging
                        but maybe not through the shareholder advocacy
                        through shareholder resolutions
                        but just engagement with companies
                        many resolutions have been withdrawn
                        that’s higher than last year
                        and a lot of times
                        that means that there was an agreement brought up
                        a lot of no action a summary of some of the proposals
                        the shareholder resolutions again
                        environment and climate change are a big
                        focus of shareholder resolutions
                        poke a push for climate transition plans
                        and greenhouse gas emission disclosure
                        a deforestation in the avocado industry
                        and tire particulate pollution tire shredding
                        and then in the financial sector
                        just scrutinizing the funding of fossil fuel projects
                        corporate
                        political influences is another big issue this year
                        lobbying transparency
                        as you see allowed exclusions for proposals
                        um
                        many of the disclose the resolutions are being blocked
                        social di topics there are many of those this year
                        and then there is an increase
                        there’s a lot of anti environmental
                        social governance proposals in this
                        shareholder resolutions
                        they’re mostly getting rejected by shareholders though
                        so why engage with companies
                        it’s another tool it’s a way to make positive change
                        through your investments as a shareholder
                        you can make an impact you don’t have to do it
                        if you invest in a fund
                        an exchange traded fund
                        a mutual fund that has similar values
                        is pushing in the direction you want to push
                        they will engage on your behalf
                        they have the knowledge staff
                        resources to be able to make changes with companies
                        there are many examples of funds
                        there are funds that do screening
                        there are funds that engage with community investment
                        and there are funds that just engage
                        they just try to make changes
                        some of them just vote on shareholder resolutions
                        and some of them bring up shareholder resolutions
                        engage with companies to make positive changes
                        you can
                        well you’re right
                        as a shareholder is vote file resolution sue
                        but you can let the funds do this
                        you don’t have to be doing this as an investor
                        and then you can bring up resolutions
                        you can vote on resolutions
                        and you can engage with corporations
                        you own a part of the company
                        you are an owner and can make
                        especially if you add your resources to other
                        like minded investors you can make changes in companies
                        voting is crucial
                        you can demand transparency
                        you can influence supply chains corporate contributions
                        sustainability greenhouse gas emission disclosure
                        there are a lot of issues
                        you can affect and we’ll go over them
                        we’ll go over some of those that are being proposed
                        or that are being worked on this year
                        in overview
                        the drop is a lot because of these rule changes
                        SCC policy changes and political pressure
                        it’s unfortunate but
                        that’s the environment we’re dealing with right now
                        it doesn’t mean we shouldn’t engage
                        it doesn’t mean we shouldn’t try hard to make positive
                        changes and
                        if the government’s not gonna make positive changes
                        it’s a way to make changes and push
                        because these companies
                        do influence our political system
                        why the drop
                        t C C rule changes
                        long approved proposals are not being allowed
                        private negotiations to avoid backlash
                        so environmental social governance categories
                        these are the main areas that are being worked on
                        largest is climate change
                        corporate political influence
                        a big amount of anti environmental management
                        and then you’ve got human rights
                        diversity at work sustainable governance
                        health and safety decent workplace climate again
                        always an issue
                        transition planning is the biggest piece
                        climate financing is a big piece
                        disclosure greenhouse gas emission disclosure plastics
                        food waste
                        we’ll go over some of these so emissions proposals
                        these are some of the companies being targeted
                        the resolution topic and who’s pushing that forward
                        Green Century is a mutual fund company
                        as you so puts out this report each year
                        there are great non profit
                        trying to make changes through shareholder engagement
                        and and this is the format we’re going to see in all
                        of these proposals
                        uh climate transition proposals 38 filed
                        I think with the previous slide too
                        this is just an example
                        of the ones that have been filed
                        some of them get filed and get withdrawn
                        if the company does and the advocate
                        and the proponent come to an agreement
                        a trillium here but companies and the resolutions
                        adopt greenhouse gas targets
                        and issue transition plans
                        align with the 1.5 degrees
                        just transition proposals
                        climate finance proposals
                        so these are for institutions financing fossil fuel
                        disclose clean energy supply finance ratio
                        just a lot of its disclosure measure disclose reduce
                        disclose carbon offset
                        so this is carbon offset accounting proposals
                        methane proposals
                        environmental management
                        I guess some of the biggest are water use and risks
                        waste and pollution
                        we’re early in the season so this number will grow
                        antimicrobial proposal
                        biodiversity deforestation proposals
                        food waste proposals
                        mining plastic proposals water certification proposals
                        human rights
                        well in the pretty similar standards and ethics racism
                        environmental justice
                        I guess digital content so human rights policies
                        indigenous people’s rights proposals
                        environmental justice proposals
                        human rights rest data Protection
                        AI reporting human rights impact
                        child safety proposals
                        data Protection forced labor
                        hate speech
                        health and safety proposals
                        we’ve got some health proposals
                        tax transparency
                        decent work freedom of association proposals
                        living wage worker health and safety
                        diversity at work
                        d I Metric Metrics and Data Proposals
                        d a Policy Proposals
                        some data proposals
                        corporate political influence
                        this is always a big one
                        lobbying elections are the big ones
                        so political contribution proposals
                        lobby ing proposals and a lot of this is just report
                        just disclose value congruency proposals
                        as you so did a proposal there
                        sustainable governance
                        board composition
                        try to get a diverse board of directors
                        environmental social governance reporting proposal
                        compensation proposals
                        voting rights proposals
                        anti environmental social governance
                        there are quite a few of proposals that are against
                        environmental social governance
                        again
                        most of those are getting defeated by shareholders
                        withdraws there’s a lot of withdrawals
                        and that’s fine if they’ve negotiated
                        if they’ve worked something out
                        pull the shareholder resolution
                        make it not public just make changes
                        CC is tightening inclusion rules
                        anti
                        esg environmental social governance is rising
                        we’ve already discussed this
                        most almost all are getting defeated
                        why shareholder advocacy matters
                        it makes a change you’re a shareholder
                        you can make a change sometimes
                        you can’t count on the government making a change
                        greater accountability align investments with values
                        influence sustainable business practices
                        I’m with AIO Financial
                        we help get clients aged with their investments
                        we have a questionnaire
                        just to make sure your investments
                        if you want them to match your values
                        so that they’re engaging on your behalf
                        they’re voting on your behalf they’re
                        working with companies to make positive changes
                        feel free to call us AIO financial.com
                        we offer a free consultation
                        we have some tools on our website
                        AIO financial.com let me know if you have any questions
                        let me know if you have any comments
                        it’s just a brief summary
                        we use a tool called your stake
                        to evaluate the impact of proposals
                        we can compare portfolios
                        let us know if we can help
                        alright take care
                        thank you for watching

                        The post Proxy Season 2025: How Shareholders Are Making an Impact Amid Political Pushback appeared first on AIO Financial - Fee Only Financial Advisors.

                        ...more
                        View all episodesView all episodes
                        Download on the App Store

                        Values Investors Podcast | Socially Responsible Investing, ESG, Ethical, Impact, Sustainable InvestmentsBy Bill Holliday, CFP