With Steam Sale season upon us, it's time to finally finish up some backlog. With that in mind, for what we promise is the last time, Jeff and J.D. finally lay to rest one of the more controversial games of this year, as well as one of the more universally praised games (and a couple others chocked in for good measure). Then it's on to the big news items of the week, including a return of what may be the best console of all time, a suppressed debate on Dark Souls' online mode, and a few more things up our sleeves.