They've been threatening to do it for weeks, now, and J.D. and Jeff finally have done it, the madmen: they've pulled up a list of the top-rated games of all time, and they're going to talk about them, by gum. In the more here-and-now, meanwhile, Geoff Keighley has summoned the powers that be to determine what games were the best this year, and we're ready to chat about that, too. Plus: impressions of Hitman 2 (2018), and the tons of indie games J.D. has played since besting God of War.