Following the discovered bodies of Kristin Bennett and Rhonda Jones discussed in Episode One, we pick back up the day after they’re found in Lumberton, North Carolina. A woman who knew Rhonda, Megan Oxendine, gave an interview to a local news station about the bodies- potentially sealing her fate of being found dead under eerie circumstances, in the same neighborhood, roughly a month later.
We explore the other secrets she might have possessed as well as official investigative reports. Additionally, Dr. Maurice Godwin provides commentary about the crime scene geography and victimology. The FBI steps up with a press conference and reward.
 
 
Music by Moonside. https://www.moonsidesound.com

Episode 2 - Punished

Dark Water Podcast is an investigative podcast exploring the mysterious depths of a Carolina community plagued by civil unrest, economic hardship, natural disasters - and a potential serial killer.

TV & Film

News

True crime

In the last episode of the year, Bret and Nick discuss listener questions, provide case updates and contemplate the future of the investigation, as well as the systemic failures that continue to prevent justice in Lumberton and beyond.

Season One - Conclusion Episode

Bret interviews the mother of victim Rhonda Jones, Sheila Price. She discusses allegations from the last anonymous podcast guest as well as claims brought to her by frightened community members. These locals propose the possibility of a serial killer, perhaps operating in the shadow of a female drug dealer and her crew of henchmen, surrounded by rumors of sadistic torture in the infamous southern town of Lumberton. Institutional failures surrounding the murders and disappearances remain painfully clear. Supposedly debunked theories continue to echo throughout this strangely complex North Carolina true crime story. 
 
Follow us on Instagram @dark_water_podcast 
for extra content, investigation updates, and more. 
 
Produced & written by Bret Andrews & Nick Andrews @naproductions
Music by Moonside @moonsidesound 
 
© Copyright 2017-2020. All Rights Reserved.

Bonus Episode - Going in Circles

Bret interviews a close friend of victim Megan Oxendine. Their dark stories allege brutal local crimes as well as corruption and conspiracy in Robeson County. A strange unsettling dream reminds us of all that’s left unanswered in our investigation of this southern true crime mystery.

Bonus Episode - A Dream with No Legs

In part two of the two-part season one finale, Bret and Nick tell you the story of their search for the truth behind a string of murders and disappearances in Lumberton, North Carolina.
Warning: This episode contains descriptions of crime, including rape and assault, which could be traumatic for some listeners.
Music by MOONSIDE

Episode 9 - Road to Nowhere Part II

In the two-part season one finale, Bret & Nick tell the story of their search for the truth behind a string of murders and disappearances in Lumberton, North Carolina. 
Music by MOONSIDE

Episode 2 - Punished

Download our free app to listen on your phone