In this episode premier episode of A Case for Grace, we explore one of the most profound and challenging questions in faith: Why does God allow suffering? Is God punitive, or is there a deeper design at play? Hosts Kate Gray and Jeff Slayter unpack the difference between a punitive view of God—where He enforces suffering as punishment—and the design law perspective, where God’s love and freedom shape our growth and healing.

We discuss scripture, the role of free will, and why trusting God’s plan can shift how we view hardship. Whether you’ve wrestled with doubts or are looking for clarity, this episode offers encouragement and hope for navigating life’s toughest questions.

0:00 - Welcome and Introduction to the Topic

1:20 - The Big Question: Why Does God Allow Suffering?

3:05 - The Punitive Lens: How We Misinterpret God’s Role

7:45 - Breaking Down the Design Law Perspective

10:15 - Scriptural Insights: Romans 8:28 and John 10:10

12:30 - How Our View of God Affects Our Daily Life

15:50 - Healing from Church Hurt and Misconceptions

18:40 - The Role of Free Will and Natural Consequences

22:10 - Avoiding Legalism and Embracing Grace

25:30 - Understanding the Spiritual Battle of Belief

29:00 - Why Relationship with God Matters Over Religion

31:15 - Final Takeaways: Trusting God’s Plan

33:10 - Conclusion and Next Steps for Listeners