What if it was the early 1600s but ALSO the mid 1990s? What if our leads were pop culture icons but ALSO kids in their first high school play? What if the director was a visionary auteur but ALSO kind of a hack? What if Paul Rudd was a decades-long mutual crush but ALSO the reason our two cohosts stop speaking to each other? Many questions are raised and none are answered in this week's trip down memory lane.

Instagram: @ReplayingFavorites