It's time to celebrate last night's Big Game with an episode that features a long basketball heavy pre-recorded segment! In all serious, Hosts James and Diaz are proud to welcome not just Very Special Guest Xavier this week, but also friend of the show and noted Haver of Hot Takes, Baltimore's own Papadop, as he brings a Guy with a controversial status for consideration.

After our trusty trio checks in on their memories of now, it's time to take a spin in the time machine back to their discussion with Papadop (16:52), where we'll see if he bricked his shot with them and got stonewalled, or broke through their defenses with a successful case (22:12). Does this Schrödinger's plaque exist already or not? After some final deliberation, the answer will be revealed with zero dead cats ! (47:28)

Theme Music by Don Ham; additional audio from Troop 41, CBS

Find more at bit.ly/rememberthatguy