This episode is brought to you by Supernatural, a Spotify Original from Parcast. For more episodes like this one, subscribe to Supernatural, free on Spotify!

Hooves, wings and high-pitched screams… The Jersey Devil has reportedly been seen thousands of times, lurking in and around a forest called the Pine Barrens. How much of its existence is rumor, and how much is reality? 

To view this episode’s full list of sources, please visit parcast.com/supernatural