This episode is brought to you by Unexplained Mysteries, a Spotify Original from Parcast. For more episodes like this one, subscribe to Unexplained Mysteries, free on Spotify!

What could possibly be buried on Oak Island that is so alluring? Some theorists suspect pirate treasure… But at least one researcher believed the Knights Templar hid an ancient relic there, like the Ark of the Covenant. Or maybe even the Holy Grail.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices