We forgo the usual show structure to compare and contrast our Halloween experiences to our kids' Halloween experiences. We took more candy than we should have when told "take one." Do we allow our kids to take more than one? We kept and ate all the candy. Is it the same for our offspring? We stayed up late on Halloween night. Is it the same now? All of that and much more, including a "Daddy Did That" segment with Markus rethinking his costume policy and how Alex succeeded in finding the perfect costume for his daughter.