On Episode 9 (Season 2) of The Dylan and Joe Show (Friday October 13, 2023), the guys start off with small talk and see Where in the World Joe has been. Joe wishes his niece, nephew and mom a very Happy Birthday. The guys are then joined by former rock band mate and friend Nate Adams (self-proclaimed horror film buff) and talk about horror films, movies and series. The trio of Young, Cantrell and Adams listen to voice memos about horror films, read a text on the subject and then move to social media to read comments submitted by listeners. After Nate departs Episode 9, Dylan and Joe provide a brief "Fantasy Football Update" for The Dylan and Joe Show's Fantasy Football League. The duo give an update for how things are going on the "College Football Pick Em" segment. The Cinemagic segment is back, this time where Dylan and Joe talk a little bit about one of their favorite tv shows at some point in their lives. Listener-favorite segment "That's Old News" takes place with a familiar voice being used in AI-fashion. Joe's memory is tested by Dylan in the "Do You Remember" segment before the show is wrapped up after "One More Thing".