In this episode of Not for the Faint, Summer dives deep into the tragic murder of Samantha Stewart, a young nurse whose online dating turns deadly after she was brutally killed in New York. This one will leave you with more questions than answers.

Then, Alyssa takes us back to the terrifying reign of Ken McElroy, a notorious bully and criminal who terrorized Skidmore, Missouri, for years. His disgusting crimes and the town’s ultimate response made headlines across the nation, leaving people questioning the limits of community retribution.