In this conversation, Nicole Poff and Kate Belknap discuss the transformative efforts at Colorado Mesa University to enhance faculty development and teaching culture. They explore the challenges faced by faculty in higher education, the importance of pedagogical training, and the initiatives implemented to foster a supportive teaching environment. The conversation highlights the significance of faculty relationships, cross-disciplinary collaboration, and the need for ongoing professional development in higher education. In this conversation, Kate Belknap and Nicole Poff discuss the challenges and strategies in higher education regarding faculty development and teaching excellence. They explore the gap between content expertise and pedagogical skills, the importance of engaging faculty in professional development, and the need for institutional support to elevate teaching practices. The discussion also touches on the potential for expanding influence beyond Colorado Mesa University and the significance of mentorship in fostering a culture of teaching excellence.