Draped in Irish mystique and enough echo to fill a stadium, we have the 2-seed "With or Without You" – U2's soaring masterpiece that turned Bono into a messianic rock god and made The Edge's guitar delay pedal famous! This atmospheric juggernaut comes loaded with enough existential angst to power a semester of college philosophy classes.

But wait – here comes our scrappy 15-seed "Against the Wind," Bob Seger's blue-collar ballad that's about as 80s as a Detroit assembly line... which, plot twist, might actually BE pretty 80s! Sure, this heartland rocker feels more like 1970s denim than 1980s synth-pop, but don't sleep on Seger's Reagan-era working-class anthem vibes and that distinctly American sound that defined the decade's grittier underbelly.

Can U2's cathedral-sized ambition steamroll the Silver Bullet Band's everyman appeal? Or will Seger's authentic Americana prove that sometimes the most 80s thing is music that sounds like it's fighting against everything the 80s represented? Time to find out if Ireland's finest can weather this Midwestern storm!

[INSERT BOB SEGER VIDEO HERE IF HE EVER MAKES ONE.]

This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit the80sest.substack.com