One Battle After Another is finally here. PTA’s new film is being praised by some as not only one of the best films of the year but of the decade so far. After a monthlong look at his filmography, Christian and Scott dive in.

Will the PTA fanboy and PTA skeptic find common ground? Or is another argument brewing? (Or, in classic Cinema on Tap fashion—both?).

Plus, we reveal who won our summer box office game and gets to pick a bonus episode later this year.

What’s your favorite PTA film? Let us know at [email protected]