Should Sally Hawkins have received her first Oscar nomination for Mike Leigh's 2008 dramedy? And could she have bested Kate Winslet to the top prize?

Cristof's Twitter: @JudgeRoySnyder | Letterboxd: @ChristofN | Sporcle: sporcle.com/user/MrWhiplash/

James' Twitter: @jimmykunovski | @outofoscarpod | Letterboxd: @jameskuno 

Intro Song: "Awards" by Alexi Action