It's Shepherd vs. the oldest Fratelli Brother from Goonies in what is basically the first part of Die Hard on Atlantis.

If you want to listen to the FULL retrospective review & recap of this episode and also get access to all our commercial-free reviews of classic sci-fi shows like Foundation, Doctor Who, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Eureka, and more, check out our members area here:

http://www.saltynerdclub.com