Did we miss a pop punk classic? The boys sit down with Say It Like You Mean It by The Starting Line properly for the first time—and consider whether they have found a hidden gem. Also: secret high school watch messages, the first albums they ever bought (huge surprises), strict parents vs Alanis Morissette and a near-plagiarism lawsuit that never was.

Next week’s album: Smash by The Offspring.

Get the rating guide at poppunkbookclub.com and rate along with us.