We’re reaching back into season 1 to bring a fan favorite episode, in case you missed it. Here’s “Put Your Dick Away, Jim” where we discuss one of our more infamous killers in the first half, and the mystery of the Sims family in the second half.

Cocktail: Hawaiian Punch Koolaid/Rum

Story A: Jim Jones, his cult, and the “Jonestown Massacre.”

Story B: The mysterious and unsolved murder of the Sims family in Tallahassee, Florida.