Valentine’s Day 1994 has arrived in this week’s episode, Season 3, Episode 2: Love Stinks. Puck juggles two dates for one Valentine’s Day, Judd puts together a Lonely Hearts dinner group for all the dateless roommates (to a place called The Stinking Rose, no less), and Pedro and Rachel have a heart-to-heart after her skedaddling during last episode’s scrapbook share. Rachel and Puck engage in a little wig-trying-on flirtation; she clearly has a thing for bad boys, but can she handle all that is Puck? Speaking of Puck, we get a lot of insight into just how disgusting his personal hygiene is, which prompts Rachel to give him a manicure “so he knows what it’s like to have clean hands.” This is also the episode of the infamous Peanut Butter Incident between Pedro and Puck, so grab yourself your own jar and dig in!

Follow us on social media! We’re @friendsamongstrangerspod on both Facebook and Instagram, and @FAS_pod on Twitter.