Annie and Aimee go down a deep wormhole after watching the 2008 documentary (?!) Catfish. What is real? What is fake? How many numbers of your credit card should you give to strangers on the internet?! We discuss internet safety and trust, unfulfilled dreams and the role of the film maker in documenting real people's lives. It turns out we both have an endless fascination with other people's fantasies and Aimee admits to her Catfish catnip probbofave. We also talk about other tales of subterfuge including Stephanie Wood's memoir Fake, Dirty John & the convoluted story behind author AJ Finn's deceptions.