The PhiloKitchen: An Unmediated Dive into Philosophical Practice

Self & World I


Listen Later

From Physiological Process to the Instance of Being

We challenge the traditional inquiry into the "inter-relation of mind and world." To ask how the mind "takes in" the world is to presuppose a dualism that a rigorous scrutiny does not support. At the fundamental level, what occurs is not an encounter between an agent and an environment, but a seamless, uninterrupted physiological event. External physicality interacts with internal physiology – matter meeting matter in a comprehensive, homogenousfabric of cause and effect.

The Limit of Causal Language

Our language fails when we attempt to describe how sovereign awareness arises from this physiological basis. Terms like "transform" or "produce" are borrowed from the physical domain and are categorically unfit to describe the emergence of experiential content. The subjective "picture" does not result from a physical transformation; it emerges as a consequence of physicality in a way that remains lguisticallyinaccessible. We lack the vocabulary for this specific consequentiality because the manifestation of the mind to itself is not a physiological event of the kind a manifestation of the flower or the tree is.

The Computer vs. the Organism

The prevailing model – where senses collect data for a brain to process into an "output" (the world-picture) – is a precise description of a computer, not a human being. A computer operates through input, processing, and output; it manages data. But the human organism, with the brain at its center, is not a processor; it is a constituent of a/the world, evolving within and as part of the very fabric it inhabits and endowing it – by that very process – the features and status of an environment.

  • Performance vs. Being: A computer can be programmed to perform in space and time, but it cannot be programmed to be. Performance is an observable sequence of operations; "Being" is an existential instance that transcends the observable. The cognitive organism is – not as infrastructure for performance but as the existential fabric thereof.
  • The Non-Imitable: One can imitate a performance, but one cannot imitate "Being in a world." Since "Being" – the conceptual framework of meaningful eventuation – resides beyond the metrics of time and space, it remains outside the reach of any computational imitation.

The Sovereign Illusion

The brain performs as part of a structure, nothing more. It does not "perceive" the world any more than the wind "perceives" the sand. Yet the operation it has evolved to enable is inextricably interwoven with a "sense of sense" – a sovereign awareness that no observable physiological operation denotes. The very concept of a "world" is a mystery of reflection that is entirely absent from the mechanical performance of the organs.

The meaningful horizon is always there while seemingly out of reach.

We proceed.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The PhiloKitchen: An Unmediated Dive into Philosophical PracticeBy Daniel Drabkin