What happens when the thing you’re asking God for is good—and He still doesn’t give it to you?
In this deeply honest conversation, Lyndsay and Lori sit down with author Heather LaVigne to talk about infertility, miscarriage, unanswered prayer, disappointment with God, and what it looks like to keep trusting Him when your story doesn’t unfold the way you believed it would.
Heather shares her own journey through years of infertility, IVF, pregnancy loss, endometriosis, and the spiritual wrestling that followed. There were seasons when she still believed the truth about God intellectually but felt completely numb toward Him emotionally—when opening her Bible felt impossible and the goodness of God felt much harder to believe than it once had.
We talk about what helped bring her back.
Not easy answers. Not Christian clichés. Not rushing through grief.
Community. Women who sat with her. Friends who prayed when she couldn’t pray. People who read Scripture over her when she couldn’t bring herself to read it. And a God who remained trustworthy even when Heather couldn’t understand what He was doing.
We also talk about how the Church can better care for women experiencing infertility and pregnancy loss, why grief shouldn’t be rushed, how suffering can expose the places where our theology needs to deepen, and the difference between God giving us the thing we desperately want and God doing something even deeper within our hearts.
If you’ve ever prayed for something good—a baby, a marriage, healing, restoration, a dream, an open door—and wondered why God hasn’t answered the way you hoped, this conversation is for you.
IN THIS EPISODE:
• Infertility, IVF, endometriosis & pregnancy loss
• Wrestling with God after unanswered prayer
• Lament and making room for grief
• Supporting a friend through miscarriage or infertility
• Finding God when you feel spiritually numb
• Trusting God’s character when you don’t understand His plan
• Biblical women who experienced barrenness, waiting & loss
• Allowing our broken places to become places God uses
RESOURCES + LINKS
📖 Barren: A Shared Journey of Infertility, Loss, and Faith — Heather LaVigne
Amazon: https://a.co/d/02S2hukR
🤍 Circle of Hope
A nationwide virtual support group for women walking through infertility, miscarriage, pregnancy loss, and related grief. Heather serves as a facilitator/moderator.
https://www.twelve12ministries.org/circleofhope
📖 The Broken Way — Ann Voskamp
Heather’s answer to the question, “What is one book besides the Bible every woman should read?”
https://annvoskamp.com/thebrokenway/
CONNECT WITH HEATHER
Website: https://heatherlavigneauthor.com
Instagram: @heatherlavigneauthor
Facebook: Heather LaVigne
SCRIPTURES & BIBLICAL STORIES MENTIONED
Psalm 33:9
James 4:7
Revelation 12:11
Luke 1 — Elizabeth
Genesis — Sarah, Rebekah, Rachel & Hagar
1 Samuel 1 — Hannah
Ruth
John 6:68 — “Lord, to whom shall we go?”
CONNECT WITH PRETTY & WISE + SHE IS HIS
More encouragement, articles, resources, events, and podcast episodes:
https://www.prettyandwise.com
Follow along on social media and make sure you follow She Is His on Spotify so you don’t miss the next conversation.