In this episode, we explore the history of Scotland's witch hunts and ask whether the persecution, silencing and control of women really belongs in the past.
I'm joined by Zoe Venditozzi and Claire Mitchell, co-authors of How to Kill a Witch: A Guide for the Patriarchy and the women behind the Witches of Scotland campaign and podcast.
Their work shone a light on the historic injustice of Scotland's witch trials, ultimately leading to a formal Scottish Government apology on International Women's Day in 2022: the first official recognition of the thousands of people, mostly women, who were accused, convicted and executed as witches.
But their work doesn't stop with history.
Because when fear, superstition and prejudice become legitimised by those in power, what can that teach us about the world we live in today?
Together, we explore how women became targets of witch hunts, how the church, law and monarchy helped create and reinforce the persecution, and what happens when society turns against its own people.
Host:
Lulu Minns is a former criminal defence lawyer, criminology lecturer and author of The Genius Wheel®. Through She Rebel Radio, she explores the stories, ideas and women that challenge the status quo and invite us to see ourselves and the world differently.
Key Takeaways: 1. Why Were Women Called Witches?
The legislation was gender neutral, so why did women make up around 85% of those accused? We explore the religious and social beliefs that made women particularly vulnerable, from Eve and the Devil to ideas about women's supposed susceptibility to evil.
2. Godly Women, Quarrelsome Women & Accused Men
It wasn't simply women who were seen as difficult or "quarrelsome" who were accused. Godly women could be targeted too. We explore the different types of women caught up in the witch trials, why being poor, older, independent or without male protection could increase vulnerability - and why men were accused too, often after being named by women.
3. How Do You Create a Witch?
A strange event. An accusation. An investigation. A confession. A name.
We explore how witch-hunts could spread through communities, including the role of interrogation and sleep deprivation, and how pamphlets warning "good Christians" to look out for witches helped create a culture of fear.
We also look at James VI and I and his Daemonologie (1597), and how the King helped shape the way witchcraft was understood and prosecuted.
4. When Fear Becomes Law
The witch trials weren't simply about superstition. We explore what happened when the church, the law and the monarchy reinforced one another - and how the trials helped police women's behaviour and reinforce the social order.
5. Witch Hunts Didn't End 400 Years Ago
What happens when a society becomes fearful and needs someone to blame?
We explore the uncomfortable parallels with today - from social anxiety and economic insecurity to debates about women's roles, immigration and the rise of religious nationalism.
Because perhaps the biggest lesson of the witch hunts is what happens when we forget our history and allow fear and prejudice to become legitimised by those in power.
Join the Conversation
We'd love to hear your reflections on this episode and the wider conversation around women, power and the lessons of history.
Share your thoughts with us using #SheRebelRadio.
Why do you think women were so much more likely to be accused of witchcraft? What happens when society decides that a particular group of people is to blame? Are there lessons from the witch trials that we still need to hear today?
References & Discussion Points
-
Venditozzi, Z. & Mitchell, C. (2024), How to Kill a Witch: A Guide for the Patriarchy. London: Mudlark.
-
Chollet, M. (2022), In Defence of Witches: Why Women Are Still on Trial. London: MacLehose Press.
-
Sheridan, S. (2019), Where Are the Women? A Guide to an Imagined Scotland. Edinburgh: Historic Environment Scotland.
-
Gibson, M: Author and Historian at Exeter University
-
James VI and I (1597), Daemonologie.
-
Witches of Scotland - campaign and podcast exploring the Scottish witch trials and their legacy.
-
The Scottish witch trials: accusation, prosecution and execution.
-
Women, power and the history of patriarchy.
-
The relationship between law, religion and social control.
-
Witch-hunting, propaganda and the role of pamphlets in shaping public fear.
-
Remembering women's history - and what happens when the state turns against its own people.
Connect With Zoe & Claire
Witches of Scotland: witchesofscotland.com
Instagram: @witches.of.scotland
Threads: @witches.of.scotland
Connect With Me
If this episode resonated with you, please subscribe, rate and review She Rebel Radio. Sharing the episode helps amplify conversations around women's stories, power, history and the systems that continue to shape women's lives.
To discover your own seven-year personal growth cycle, visit The Genius Wheel®.
Website: thegeniuswheel.com
Substack: luluminns.substack.com
LinkedIn: Lulu Minns on LinkedIn