A suspect sits in an interrogation room. He has denied everything for hours. He is confident. He is calm. He has an answer for every question. The detective does not argue. He does not raise his voice. He simply tells the suspect that a witness has come forward. He describes the witness in detail. Height, weight, clothing, location. The suspect's face changes. He asks who the witness is. The detective says he cannot reveal that information. The suspect asks for a lawyer. The detective leaves the room. The suspect confesses to his cellmate that night.

In this episode, I examine the psychological tactics that smart detectives use to elicit confessions. The bluff. The fake witness. The fabricated evidence. The Reid technique. The PEACE model. The Mr. Big sting. These methods are controversial. Some say they produce false confessions. Others say they are necessary to catch killers who would otherwise walk free.

The episode explores specific cases where detectives used deception to break suspects. A murderer who confessed after being told his DNA was found at the scene. It was not. A rapist who confessed after being told his victim had identified him from a photo lineup. She had not. The tactics are legal. The question is whether they are ethical.

Turn down the lights, put on your headphones, and press play because smart detectives know that the truth is not always enough. Sometimes you have to help a suspect find it.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/red-tree-crime--6847553/support.