Why doesn't more information automatically produce spiritual growth?

In this Greenhouse discussion, Brian Fisher and Kyle Moody continue the conversation from Episode 54 by exploring the role of instruction in spiritual formation. Together they wrestle with a common assumption in modern Christianity: that hearing enough truth will naturally transform us into people who live like Jesus.

The discussion explores the difference between learning about Jesus and experiencing Him, the value of instruction within the Five Key Elements of Formation, and why many Christians find themselves spiritually stuck despite years of sermons, classes, and Bible studies. Brian and Kyle also revisit The Critical Journey, discussing the Inward Journey, the Wall, and the deeper stages of discipleship that often receive little attention in modern church life.

Ultimately, the conversation points toward a richer understanding of formation—one that involves not only instruction, but relationship, experience, community, and intimacy with God.

Join us online! 

Web: ⁠⁠soilandroots.org⁠⁠ 

Substack: ⁠ https://soilandroots.substack.com/

In this episode, Brian Fisher begins exploring instruction as the fifth key element of formation by examining a deeper question: What if most Christian teaching only prepares us for the early stages of discipleship? Drawing on The Critical Journey by Janet Hagberg and Robert Guelich, he introduces six stages of spiritual growth and explores why many believers struggle when they encounter the Inward Journey, the Wall, and the deeper work of transformation.

Along the way, Brian revisits the Three Primary Problems, the Five Key Elements of Formation, and the role of Greenhouses as communities designed to help people navigate the full discipleship journey. The conversation challenges listeners to reconsider what spiritual formation actually requires and why information alone rarely produces the abundant life Jesus promised.

Join us online! 

Web: ⁠⁠soilandroots.org⁠⁠ 

Substack: ⁠ https://soilandroots.substack.com/

What does a mature disciple actually look like?

In this Greenhouse discussion, Brian Fisher is joined by Dr. Tim Boswell to continue the conversation from Episode 52. Together they explore the longing for deep community, the challenges of modern isolation, and the common assumptions Christians hold about spiritual maturity.

The discussion revisits three popular images of mature discipleship: the miracle-working Christian, the highly informed Christian, and the perpetually calm Christian. Along the way, Brian and Tim wrestle with questions of obedience, character, discernment, emotional health, and what it means to become more fully human as we grow closer to Jesus.

Rather than measuring maturity by knowledge, power, or personality type, this conversation points listeners back to the example of Christ—someone deeply rooted in love, truth, wisdom, and intimacy with the Father.

Join us online! 

Web: ⁠⁠soilandroots.org⁠⁠ 

Substack: ⁠ https://soilandroots.substack.com/

What does a spiritually mature Christian actually look like?

In this episode, Brian Fisher challenges several common assumptions about spiritual maturity. Many Christians assume that mature disciples are marked by supernatural power, exceptional theological knowledge, or a calm, unshakable demeanor. But do those ideas truly reflect the life of Jesus?

Drawing on examples from Scripture, church culture, and modern discipleship movements, Brian explores three popular models of maturity: the "overpowered" Christian, the "accurate" Christian, and the "placid" Christian. Along the way, he asks whether our vision of discipleship has become disconnected from the character of Christ.

The episode concludes with a compelling portrait of spiritual maturity rooted not in performance, knowledge, or emotional suppression, but in intimacy with God, authentic humanity, courageous love, and deep compassion.

Join us online! 

Web: ⁠⁠soilandroots.org⁠⁠ 

Substack: ⁠ https://soilandroots.substack.com/

Why do our actions often tell a different story than our theology?

In this Greenhouse discussion, Brian Fisher and Kyle Moody continue the conversation from Episode 50 by exploring the gap between our stated beliefs and the deeper ideas that actually shape our lives. Through personal stories and honest reflection, they wrestle with the uncomfortable reality that many of our heart-level assumptions don't always align with what we know to be true.

The discussion revisits the Six Core Ideas and explores how identity, value, power, purpose, and love are formed over time through relationships and experiences. Brian and Kyle also examine why spiritual transformation requires more than information, and why Greenhouses create space for the vulnerability, trust, and relational experiences that help our deepest ideas gradually become aligned with the ideas of Jesus.

Ultimately, this conversation offers hope that discipleship is not merely about learning new information, but about allowing God to transform the deepest parts of our hearts.

Join us online! 

Web: ⁠⁠soilandroots.org⁠⁠ 

Substack: ⁠ https://soilandroots.substack.com/

Why do Christians often believe the right things yet struggle to live them?

In this episode, Brian Fisher explores one of the most important distinctions in spiritual formation: the difference between beliefs and ideas. Drawing on the work of Dallas Willard and James K.A. Smith, he argues that our lives are shaped less by the beliefs we profess and more by the unconscious ideas and desires buried deep within our hearts.

The conversation revisits the Six Core Ideas, examines how cultural assumptions shape our understanding of God and Scripture, and explores why information alone rarely produces lasting transformation. Brian also explains how ideas are formed through relationship and experience, helping listeners understand why intimacy is such a vital element of discipleship.

If you've ever wondered why your actions don't always align with your theology, this episode offers a powerful framework for understanding how hearts are actually transformed.

Join us online! 

Web: ⁠⁠soilandroots.org⁠⁠ 

Substack: ⁠ https://soilandroots.substack.com/

Why can church groups still feel lonely?

In this Greenhouse discussion, Brian Fisher and Kyle Moody continue the conversation from Episode 48 by exploring intimacy, vulnerability, and the risk of being known. They discuss why many small groups function more as fellowship or information groups than truly formative communities, and why that often leaves people longing for something deeper.

The conversation explores how trusted relationships shape our experience of God, why intimacy requires risk, and why being real with God and others is essential to spiritual formation. Brian and Kyle also reflect on the difference between polite Christian connection and the kind of community where people can bring their doubts, fears, wounds, and questions honestly.

This episode expands the Season 3 discussion of intimacy as one of the Five Key Elements of Formation.

Join us online! 

Web: ⁠⁠soilandroots.org⁠⁠ 

Substack: ⁠ https://soilandroots.substack.com/

Why do so many Christians feel lonely despite being surrounded by people?

In this episode, Brian Fisher explores the relationship between intimacy, vulnerability, and spiritual formation. Drawing on insights from John Calvin, Curt Thompson, C.S. Lewis, Rosaria Butterfield, and others, he argues that our relationships with God, ourselves, and other people are deeply interconnected. To know God more deeply often requires learning how to know ourselves and allowing ourselves to be genuinely known by trusted others.

The conversation examines the modern loneliness epidemic, why many churches unintentionally reinforce isolation, and how fear, shame, and image management keep us from experiencing authentic community. Brian also explores why intimacy is inherently risky and why meaningful relationships require the courage to be vulnerable.

Ultimately, this episode offers a compelling vision for recapturing the kind of New Testament community where people are known, loved, challenged, and transformed together.

Join us online! 

Web: ⁠⁠soilandroots.org⁠⁠ 

Substack: ⁠ https://soilandroots.substack.com/

Is the world getting worse, or are Christians looking at the wrong story?

In this Greenhouse discussion, Brian Fisher and Kyle Moody continue unpacking the themes from Episode 46 by exploring Christian fatalism, the Gospel of the Kingdom, and how our expectations shape the way we live. Together they wrestle with a common assumption in modern Christianity: that the world is inevitably declining and that the church's primary responsibility is simply to endure until the end.

The conversation examines the influence of dispensationalism, the relationship between suffering and redemption, and why the Kingdom of God offers a more hopeful vision of reality. Brian and Kyle also discuss the importance of formative community, arguing that deep discipleship requires people who can walk with us through suffering rather than merely explain it away.

Along the way, they ask a provocative question: If Jesus truly defeated sin, death, and evil, what should Christians expect from His Kingdom in the present world?

Join us online! 

Web: ⁠⁠soilandroots.org⁠⁠ 

Substack: ⁠ https://soilandroots.substack.com/

Why do so many sincere Christians struggle to become more like Jesus?

In this bonus episode, Brian Fisher brings together the major themes of Soil & Roots and argues that many discipleship efforts fail because they are missing two essential components. While spiritual formation remains the heart of discipleship, formation alone is not enough. Christians also need a compelling vision of the Kingdom of God and a community specifically designed to support transformation.

Using a framework called the "Discipleship Sandwich," Brian explains how the Forgotten Kingdom, the Discipleship Dilemma, and the Formation Gap work together to shape the spiritual lives of modern believers. He explores why Christian fatalism has weakened the church's influence, why discipleship must extend beyond information and habits, and why transformation happens most effectively in committed communities built around time, habits, community, intimacy, and instruction.

If you've ever wondered why spiritual growth can feel difficult despite your best efforts, this episode offers a practical framework for understanding how deep discipleship actually works.

Join us online! 

Web: ⁠⁠soilandroots.org⁠⁠ 

Substack: ⁠ https://soilandroots.substack.com/