In November of 1985, a 67-year-old retired man named Dexter Stefonek was driving home to Wisconsin after spending a few months in Oregon with his son and grandchildren. It was bitter cold across Montana. He had been making good time, driving straight through, stopping only when he had to. Late one night, he pulled into a rest stop along the interstate. By morning, his car was a burned-out shell still smoking in the cold air. And Dexter was gone.His son David had tried to talk him out of making the drive. He told his father the weather was going to be rough and it was a long trip for a man his age. Dexter had lost his wife of 44 years just the year before, on Christmas Day 1984, and David wanted him to stay through the winter so he wouldn't be alone. Dexter waved him off and said he'd be fine. He wanted to be home.A custodian working the rest stop that night had seen the whole thing. He watched a man climb out of Dexter's Mercury with 2 gas cans, soak the car down, and light it on fire. Then the man walked away, got into a white pickup truck with Arizona plates that had come back around, and drove off into the dark.Investigators searched the rest stop and the surrounding area and found nothing. They put out alerts, checked other rest stops along the interstate, and traced the white pickup as far as they could without a plate number. The case went cold. There were no cameras, no digital trail, and almost no way to track a vehicle across state lines in 1985.Five months later, a couple searching a landfill about 20 miles from the rest stop found a wallet on the ground. Inside was Dexter's driver's license and a significant amount of cash. They kept looking. They found a suitcase. Some clothes. And then, under an old mattress, they found what was left of Dexter. He had been there since November, right around the time his car burned at the rest stop.Nothing valuable had been taken. The wallet still had cash. The suitcase had money too. This was not a robbery. Whoever did this did not want Dexter's money or his things. Investigators concluded that Dexter had simply been in the wrong place at the wrong time, chosen at random by someone who had done this before and knew exactly how to disappear afterward.The case stayed open for years, then decades. The white pickup was never found. The man the custodian saw setting the fire was never identified. David lived with the knowledge that he had tried to stop his father from making that drive, and it had not been enough.Then in 2019, nearly 40 years later, investigators ran Dexter's case through a national DNA database as a matter of routine. It matched a man already in prison for a different murder. When investigators looked at where he had been in the fall of 1985, it was Montana. He had owned a white pickup truck with Arizona plates. He matched the description the custodian had given the night of the fire.His name was Charles Sullivan. He had been doing this for years before Dexter. He had no reason to choose Dexter specifically. He didn't need one. He just needed someone alone on a cold highway at night, and that night it was a 67-year-old man who only wanted to get home.Sullivan has never confessed. He lawyered up the moment investigators came to talk to him and has gone quiet ever since.

For the FULL experience, watch this story as a Video on our YouTube channel here:

⁠youtube.com/@talesfromtheglovebox⁠