A prominent judge in West Palm Beach, Florida disappears. The case goes cold for five years. How does a seemingly unconnected murder help solve a cold case?

Billy Jack Gaither is a middle aged man living in Sylacauga, Alabama in 1999 just trying to do the right thing by taking care of his ailing parents. When he decides to leave his home late one Friday night, his family's lives are changed forever.

A young couple in Knoxville, Tennessee is headed out for the night when they become the victims of a carjacking but what happened next made them two of the most brutal murder victims in the state. Will the five suspects be let off because of a judge's bad behavior?

A young Texas mother starts to have hallucinations and says God was constantly ordering her to harm her children. Do psychiatric experts actually believe her claims?

In March 2005, a man on trial for raping his ex-girlfriend escapes custody and sends Atlanta, Georgia into a frenzy for 26 hours of terror. How did he escape and how was he finally apprehended?

Suzanne Collins was a 19-year-old Lance Corporal in the Marines stationed in Tennessee and set to graduate from aviation training on the very day she was abducted while out jogging and brutally raped and murdered. But is the man who confessed really the one responsible for her death?

A mentally handicapped African American man confesses to the 1983 Arkansas murder of a white Air Force nurse but the evidence doesn't match his confession. What happens next?

A North Carolina man makes it his mission to become the boogeyman in his small Christian town. Does he succeed?

Trisha Stemple is found dead by the side of the road near her abandoned car in Oklahoma in 1996. Does her husband's affair with a young fast food worker have anything to do with it?

Johnnie Allbritton is a 65-year-old Texas rancher gunned down in his home in what appears to be an attempted burglary. Decades pass without any leads until the small town of Buffalo brings in some famous assistance.