In 2005, 20-year-old Ryan Ferguson was convicted and sentenced to 40 years in prison for murdering Missouri sports reporter Kent Heitholt but did he actually do it?

Madison takes us back to Ozark for a cold case from the 1990s and Hilary shares the story of a not so loving wife in Edgewater, Florida.

Susan Hamilton is found murdered in her bathroom on Valentine's Day 2001 in Oklahoma City. By all accounts, she and her husband Dr. John Hamilton have a great relationship...but could he have snapped?

Wilson Robitaille has plans to rob an elderly couple in Hamilton, Alabama when his plans change last minute and take a turn for the worse.

A professor from Chicago leaves the city with his gay lover to escape modern day conveniences and build an isolated mansion in the woods of Georgia dedicated to sex and Satanism.

Lillian Madison is 8 months pregnant when she is found floating in a reservoir in Richmond, Virginia in 1885. Coroners rule it a suicide but then one of her cousins is named as a suspect.

First, Ellen covers the case of Christine Paolilla, a Texas teen who struggles to find friends when an older bad boy starts to show her affection and things go downhill. Then, Madison warns us about the dangers of Tianna.

When Britt Hall is found shot and killed in his Georgia home, his wife Michelle says he committed suicide...however the evidence presents another theory.

66-year-old Mattie Basinger is found murdered in her home in Little Rock, Arkansas. Who's the crackhead to blame?

Early Christmas morning of 1945, a fire breaks out in the Sodder home in West Virginia. George, Jennie and four of their children make it out but five of them are left inside. Why can't they find any remains?