Send us Fan Mail
Social media platforms are private businesses, and that means they can ban you, shadow ban you, or tank your reach for almost any reason they want, with zero legal recourse on your end. Mike breaks down the actual legal reality behind a call he got this week from a creator whose live audience collapsed from 5,000 viewers to barely a dozen, seemingly overnight.
That conversation opens Episode 87 of Start It or Scrap It, and it leads into a full breakdown of branding versus pay-per-click advertising, the hardest lesson both hosts learned this year about how fast their own industries are changing, and a long discussion on how AI is already reshaping farming, one of the last industries people assume is safe from it.
In this episode:
Why social media platforms are private businesses that can remove or limit you for almost any reason, and why the First Amendment doesn't apply
What shadow banning actually is, and why appealing one is often a dead end even with video evidence
A real case study: how running Facebook ads for a local mechanic nearly doubled his Google Ads conversion rate within 45 days, with zero direct return from the Facebook spend itself
A barstool company case study: five months to build a winning ad campaign, eleven days for one bad automated setting to undo it
Why every industry, from law to plumbing to farming, has some version of an AI reckoning coming, and why waiting to think about it is the expensive mistake
A real story about a farmer whose land had to be legally reclassified as an airport just to get permits for his agricultural drones
Why cross-pollinating with other creators, not just posting more, is one of the most effective (and most overlooked) ways to grow
Timestamps
0:00 Cold open: social media platforms are private businesses
0:44 Intro and welcome
2:03 A golf grip fix that explains itself
3:29 Tripling output running two remote Claude instances at once
3:53 Claude 5.1 and the new AI text watermarking
4:36 How AI text watermarking actually works
6:29 Why the EU is pushing AI watermark detection, and the "AI slop" problem
8:27 The call that opens the episode: a creator's live audience collapsed from 5,000 to a dozen
9:54 The legal reality: social media platforms are private businesses
10:29 What platforms can and can't discriminate against you for
11:11 What shadow banning actually is
12:22 A case for the platforms: AI moderation at an impossible scale
14:36 Why creators are diversifying platforms, and why creator counts have exploded
17:14 Why posting natively gets 10x the views of third-party scheduling tools
19:01 Their own show's viewership story: from hundreds live to a dozen
20:03 Censorship, or something else entirely?
23:04 Viewer question: balancing short-term revenue with long-term brand building
25:34 Branding vs. marketing: the difference that actually matters
26:07 The lawn sign example: why name recognition works on you without you noticing
28:19 Pay-per-click vs. branding, explained through an auto mechanic
30:48 Case study: Facebook ads nearly doubled a mechanic's Google Ads conversion rate
32:13 Case study: a barstool company's record sales, and how 11 days undid 5 months of work
34:44 Why Morgan & Morgan spends a billion dollars a year on marketing
35:42 Viewer question: the hardest lesson learned this past year
37:23 A hacked website, 2.6 million indexed pages, and a broken rulebook
39:24 Why every major technology gets doubted before it becomes essential
41:04 Early adopters win. Everyone else plays catch-up.
44:15 The real lesson: figure out how AI affects your industry before it's too late
44:44 "AI won't replace farmers": a real debate
46:41 A farmer's land had to be reclassified as an airport to fly his drones
47:54 Autonomous farm equipment and remote-controlled farmland
49:49 Viewer question: should you run separate business and personal social accounts?
51:26 A burnout story: when social media stopped being fun
54:38 Structuring multiple accounts: discovery vs. booking vs. business
57:21 Cross-pollination: one of the most underused growth strategies
1:00:36 Wrap-up and a scheduling note for next week
Hosted by Mike Terkanian (business attorney) and Gummi Sigurdarson (marketing expert)
Watch the full episode: https://youtu.be/SbLgT48Cvy4
Follow Start It or Scrap It:
Instagram: https://instagram.com/startitorscrapit
TikTok: https://tiktok.com/@start.it.or.scrap.it
X: https://x.com/StartItScrapIt
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/startitorscrapit/
#socialmedia #branding #marketing #ai #startitorscrapit #entrepreneur #smallbusiness #founders #shadowban #businessgrowth