Was Julianne Moore’s performance in Still Alice worthy of the Academy Award? That’s the question we asked ourselves before watching Moore’s turn as a middle-aged woman dealing with early-onset Alzheimer’s disease.

In our discussion, we analyze the highs and lows of Moore’s performance, praise Kristen Stewart and Alec Baldwin, and commend the film’s cinematography.

Also: We each share what we’ve been watching lately during a wide-ranging conversation that touches on everything from the ending of Blade Runner to The Avengers: Age of Ultron.